Economic Fundamentals: Milton Friedman On The Minimum Wage
As a follow up to yesterday's post, I offer this short video of the great economist, Milton Friedman, as he discusses the minimum wage...
Sales, marketing, business, and Internet tips for service businesses, such as plumbing, HVAC contractors, and other small business entrepreneurs.
As a follow up to yesterday's post, I offer this short video of the great economist, Milton Friedman, as he discusses the minimum wage...
The government has just declared that anyone lacking the skills to produce at least $7.25 per hour for an employer has no right to work. How stupid.
The last thing anyone should want in a recession is barriers to employment. But that's what the government did by allowing an automatic increase in the minimum wage to take effect, raising it to $7.25 per hour. A higher minimum wage makes it harder for the least skilled to find employment simply because they aren't worth fully burdened cost.
Fully burdened? Don't forget the employer's share of payroll taxes, which includes social security, medicare, and unemployment taxes. And don't forget any benefits the employer voluntarily pays.
Arguments for a higher minimum wage center on "economic justice," which translates into justice for some at the expense of others. Other arguments are that people should be able to earn a "living wage." Still others claim the minimum wage needs to rise to account for the effects of inflation.
Why $7.25?
Let's buy the arguments. Let's say that it's unjust for people to earn less than a "living wage" and raise the minimum wage accordingly. However, if we're going to hike the mimimum wage, why stop at $7.25? That's not economic justice. If we're going to raise it, why not raise it to $20 per hour? Or $200?
Clearly, a $200 per hour minimum wage would be foolish. No one will pay $200 per hour for someone to flip burgers or greet people entering a store. But at what point is the minimum not foolish?
The fact is that the minimum wage is arbitrary at any level. No business is going to hire someone for $X per hour if the person can't generate at least $X per hour of value.
The Minimum Is Not Permanent
Politicans act like the minimum wage is permanent. Anyone earning it will always earn it. That's hardly the way it works. People work for lower wages while acquiring the skills and work history that enables them to increase their productivity and command greater wages in the future.
My first job involved working for a roofing contractor... during the summer... in Texas... at age 15... for $2 per hour. If there's ever a situation where a worker was exploited, paying a kid who was too young to work, wages below the minimum wage to shingle roofs in triple digit temperatures is it.
Yet I hardly felt exploited. I was thrilled to have a job and prove myself. Yet, my employer had to break the law to hire me and pay me what I was worth (and given my ineptitude, $2 an hour was generous).
By the end of the summer I turned 16 and managed to talk my way into a job in an air conditioned restaurant. Ahhhhhh!
Part of the reason I got the job was that I had demonstrated a willingness to work hard and reliability working as a roofer. Even so, I started at minimum wage. Fortunately, the minimum wage was low. If it had been a whole lot higher, the restaurant would have hired someone with more direct experience.
Even though I started at the minimum wage, I didn't stay there. Gradually I earned a small raise. It felt good. I was proud of my progression.
By forcing companies to pay a minimum wage, a whole class of lower skill workers will never be given the chance to learn a job and get better at it so they can earn more. Instead, they'll learn that there's little "economic justice" for the unskilled.
Inflation
Inflation is hardly a justification for the current hike in the minimum wage. Indeed, raising the minimum wage will cause inflation.
Two years ago, the minimum wage was $5.15 per hour. Today, it's $7.25. That's a 41% artificial, government imposed mandate. How is that not inflationary?
Raising the minimum wage also pushes up union wages. James Sherk, the Bradley Fellow in Labor Policy in the Center for Data Analysis at The Heritage Foundation, explains...
Unions campaign to raise the minimum wage at least in part because it enriches them. Raising the minimum wage makes unskilled workers more expensive for businesses to hire, and so hiring skilled and highly paid union members becomes a more attractive choice. This effect increases union members' earned income but reduces low-income workers' job prospects and income. That unions support raising the minimum wage is understandable, but antipoverty advocates should reconsider their support for a policy that hurts the very people they seek to help.

According to the 1981 Report of the Minimum Waqe Study Commission, the 46 percent rise in the minimum wage between 1977 and 1981 destroyed 644,000 jobs among teenagers alone. "The evidence is now in, and the findings of dozens of major economic studies show that the damage done by the minimum wage has been far more severe than even the critics . . . predicted." A 1983 survey, "Time-Series Evidence of the Effect of the Minimum Wage on Youth Employment," found that studies conducted between 1973 and 1983 generally agreed that a 10 percent increase in the minimum wage would result in a 1 to 3 percent reduction in teenage employment. Given these findings, the proposal to raise the minimum wage by nearly 40 percent could result in a 4 to 12 percent drop in the employment of teens.